Skip to content

Contradiction by Calvin Klein

Men 1999

Perfumer
Carlos Benaïm
Perfumer
Pierre Wargnye

Description

Contradiction by Calvin Klein is a woody oriental fragrance for men. Launched in 1999, this composition was created by Carlos Benaïm and Pierre Wargnye. The top notes reveal a vibrant accord of lime, lavender, lemon, helichrysum and mandarin; the heart unfolds a complex spice blend featuring pepper, cardamom, coriander and nutmeg; while the base notes offer a warm and persistent…

Show more

Quick summary

When to wear it (votes)

  • Winter 13%
  • Spring 35%
  • Summer 24%
  • Autumn 29%
  • Day 71%
  • Night 29%

Key notes

Community

974 votes

  • Positive 77%
  • Negative 16%
  • Neutral 7.2%
positive reviews 974 community votes
LongevityModerate SillageModerate Best momentDay CharacterMasculine

The olfactory pyramid

A guide to the opening, heart and lasting trail of the fragrance.

The community speaks

Compare the results and tap an answer to add your vote.

In the collection

Leading answer I owned it

2,778 votes

Season

Choose several

Leading answer Spring

1,042 votes

Time of day

Choose several

Leading answer Day

607 votes

Each question has its own vote count. You can choose several seasons.

Fragrance profile

About Contradiction

Main accord aromatic Year 1999 Gender Men Perfumer Carlos Benaïm · Pierre Wargnye

Contradiction by Calvin Klein is a woody oriental fragrance for men. Launched in 1999, this composition was created by Carlos Benaïm and Pierre Wargnye. The top notes reveal a vibrant accord of lime, lavender, lemon, helichrysum and mandarin; the heart unfolds a complex spice blend featuring pepper, cardamom, coriander and nutmeg; while the base notes offer a warm and persistent foundation of vetiver, musk, sandalwood and ebony wood.

Flowers Green, herbal and fougère Spices Woods and mosses

How it wears

Compare the results and tap an answer to add your vote.

Longevity

Leading answer Moderate

431 votes

Sillage

Leading answer Moderate

479 votes

Character

Leading answer Traditionally masculine

247 votes

Value perception

Leading answer Good value

223 votes

Community reviews

52 reviews

Share what you noticed: opening, drydown, sillage and the moments when it works for you.

Write a review

Add your review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.

Your rating optional
Your take, in one line optional
Your take, in one line

  1. Bruno.encens

    Contradiction is probably one of Calvin Klein’s most underrated fragrances. I recently finished a decant that had been forgotten in a drawer for over 10 years and as soon as I sprayed it, it instantly took me back to the late ’90s and early 2000s, a time when I wore this fragrance a great deal and that brought me back to my secondary school years. It has an elegant and slightly cool cleanliness so characteristic of that era. It is not a perfume designed to impress instantly. It has a fresh and classic opening, with a dry and herbal edge where lime is clearly the star, with that acidic, green and slightly sharp touch. Lavender is very well judged, clean and elegant, whilst clary sage adds an aromatic nuance that gives it a lot of character. Little by little the spices come through and it still feels clean, but it starts to become warmer, more masculine and slightly sensual. Cardamom feels green yet sweet, working perfectly with pepper, whilst coriander brings a dry elegance that I think makes the perfume stand out and stops it becoming generic. Vetiver softens the base, gives it structure and prevents any excess sweetness. It does not evolve a great deal, rather than changing it slowly fades on the skin. Everything is very well blended, controlled and smoothed, and that gives it enormous sophistication with a clean-skin feeling. Projection and sillage are close, but that is precisely part of its charm, it never bothers, never intrudes and never tires. An office perfume in the best possible sense. Perfect for everyday wear, autumn, spring and even a mild summer. It may no longer have the performance of old, but for me it remains special, even if its statement is more subtle than striking. A forgotten gem that I have enjoyed again with that decant and that has brought back a piece of my own history. Score: 7

    Reply
  2. Not bad, a fragrance from many years ago, it projects little, low sillage, although it has a modest price, I would hardly buy it again.

    Reply
  3. Elias.osmanthus

    Contradiction by Calvin Klein. Fragrance that passed through my collection without distinction. It was a very metallic citrus fragrance that I never quite liked. It belonged to that breed of perfumes where I sprayed a lot to finish it quickly. It had a bitter grapefruit touch at the opening to then give way to the middle notes where pepper and cinnamon were predominant. Calvin Klein has been one of those houses born to break the mould but then ended up releasing an extravagant number of very low-quality fragrances, almost like supermarket perfumes. How far behind are the Eternity and the Escapes! Decent, nothing more. I would not buy it again. Rating: 4/10

    Reply
  4. silas_vetiver

    This perfume, despite being delicious, its spicy notes gave me a headache. It was something truly contradictory, because I liked its scent but it was too heavy for me, and worst of all, it was my brother’s signature perfume for a long time. The longevity was brutal and so was the sillage. One of those perfumes they no longer make.

    Reply
  5. Opening similar to 212 VIP, a very nice lime. Then it dries down and has a classic structure, lavender in the middle phase and vetiver in the dry-down. Safe, inoffensive option for every day. Lasts 6 hrs and projects for the first hour, overspraying on the shirt it lasts the whole working day no problem. Rating 8.5/10

    Reply
  6. The first time I wore it in the late 90s, I remember always getting compliments, I suppose tastes have evolved, although I still buy it and young people especially ask me in a positive way what it is, it is undeniably still a classic and classics are forever.

    Reply
  7. It’s an infamous fragrance, after buying it logically blind, if you test it you run away, I’ve used it as a bathroom air freshener.

    Reply
  8. dario_mimosa

    Cutting-edge perfume, the current batches are said to lack longevity, when I used it it projected an excellent aroma and an exquisite dry-down, I recommend it for formal occasions.

    Reply
  9. Teo.labdanum

    Aromatic, citrusy, fresh and earthy, that’s what I perceived from the very first spray, it smells really lovely, masculine and fresh for summer nights, although its duration is very short, 3 or 4 hrs at most.

    Reply
  10. I’ll start with the most important thing, it’s its poor or rather non-existent longevity (and projection obviously), as with all CK products. Perhaps it’s my skin, but it neither lasts nor manages to reveal all the notes or appreciate that exquisite scent that others appreciate. To me it is very similar to Montblanc Individuel, but more watered down and without so much character. Dispensable.

    Reply
  11. LeaOsmanthus

    Exquisite sophisticated scent it reminded me for a moment of Pierre Cardin the one in the green box note (it doesn’t appear in the database here) a combination of woods and citruses that wraps you and leaves a charming pleasant balanced sillage its presence on my skin is about 6 hours not bad I give it a 9/10 I fell in love with this fragrance.

    Reply
  12. I still don’t understand why they always expect a fragrance to please others? If that’s what they want, ask others what fragrances they like and buy it, I loved this fragrance, I’d never owned it, but I had smelt it when it came out and I finally bought it and I love it even if others don’t tell me anything, nor tell me I smell nice, I enjoy it when I smell it.

    Reply
  13. It’s a fragrance that can’t be missing from my collection, with an uncommon aroma. It goes through a variety of changes as the hours pass, it feels very fresh and spicy in the opening, then some woody notes. But if you’re in extreme heat, the mandarin stands out (spectacular). Although it hasn’t had many reviews. I’ll buy it again and again. Brilliant

    Reply
  14. Bruno.neroli

    I bought it following other users’ comments, but it turned out not to be as good as they say… It doesn’t stand out in any aspect… It’s a not at all spectacular fragrance that you can wear daily but without causing anything extraordinary in yourself or in others… Scent: 8 Sillage: 7 Longevity: 8

    Reply
  15. Contradiction is a perfume I have known for a long time. For me it is a classic that never goes out of fashion. The opening is quite citrusy and aromatic, lime and mandarin feeling very well; surprisingly the citrus is not the usual sharp and fresh one, but lavender and clary sage soften it to offer a blend towards soapy that gives a traditional barbershop clean feeling. Very neat. From the start you feel the pepper, which gains body at the same time as the citrus fades and delivers to the nose a more balsamic accord along with lavender and clary sage that keep being perceived. At certain moments, cardamom says it is there and stings a little sugary, very nice. It stays in those neat accords and without too much evolution during the first hour and a half, even two hours depending on pH and climate, when you can already appreciate the vetiver peeking through and giving the fragrance the definitive masculine touch. This makes it lose the unisex nuance it may have had at first and which I certainly never saw clearly. It is an exquisite perfume, with class. It makes you feel good, confident, clean and dynamic. With reasonable projection and longevity it is excellent for the office in not excessively hot temperatures. I see it more for formal settings, although on spring and autumn nights it is ideal for outings with friends or family. I don’t know if it is still in production, later I will look at the batch of the bottle and post it for you. It can still be found online and at a very interesting price of about £20. I recommend its use from age 30 on; not because it looks classic on young people, but because there are better fragrances for these age ranges and it doesn’t seem to me to match the taste of current trends. In my collection it will always be, that’s for sure. For me it is a hidden jewel of perfumery. Greetings fragrance lovers!!! NOTE: I checked on checkfresh and the manufacturing date is May 2018. 1 year before the purchase date.

    Reply
  16. Very citrusy and shrill opening that turns subtly into what reminds me of the smell of a lipstick. When it settles the screams of the opening become something calm and peaceful that invites relaxation. The drydown is the best part and I see it as unisex.

    Reply
  17. In my opinion Calvin Klein’s Contradiction is the only perfume that is timeless I mean… If someone walks past you wearing Obsession or Escape or ONE you recognise them immediately and you know their glory days are over. CK’s Contradiction is a perfume that has class. The top notes lavender mandarin are quickly overshadowed by pepper, coriander and musk, in my opinion this perfume is the smell of a “powerful man”

    Reply
  18. A Very Special Perfume as it gives off a sillage to a cold cold place but it really is unique, it brings me fond memories …!!!

    Reply
  19. At the start lime stands out and somewhat mandarin. later it evolves following the spices, especially cardamom and pepper, with some coriander. It has too classic a drydown and by now very generic in masculine perfumes of this type. I find that this perfume has nothing oriental since I don’t notice sandalwood much and even less ebony wood. For me its true classification is Woody spicy. It hasn’t got great sillage and its longevity is moderate. And I can’t explain how on English Fragrantica many people have found it similar to Chanel’s Égoïste, which I also own. They have no resemblance in my opinion. The strength and expressiveness of the Chanel’s sandalwood is enough to differentiate it from this CK.

    Reply
  20. I still don’t understand why people always expect a fragrance to please others? If that’s what they want, ask others which fragrances they like and buy that one. I loved this fragrance; I’d never owned it, but I had smelled it when it came out and finally bought it, and I love it even if no one says anything to me, or says I smell lovely, I enjoy it just smelling it.

    Reply
  21. Contradiction is a perfume I’ve known for a long time. For me it’s a favourite classic that never goes out of style. The opening is quite citrusy and aromatic, with lime and mandarin coming through very nicely; surprisingly the citrus is not the usual sharp and fresh one, but lavender and clary sage soften it to offer a blend towards the soapy that gives a traditional barbershop clean feeling. Very neat. From the start you can feel the pepper, which gains body at the same time as the citrus fades and delivers to the nose a more balsamic accord together with the lavender and clary sage that are still perceptible. At certain moments, the cardamom makes its presence known and stings a little sweetly, very lovely. It stays in those neat accords without too much evolution during the first hour and a half, even two hours depending on pH and climate, when you can already appreciate the vetiver peeking through and giving the fragrance the definitive masculine touch. This makes it lose the unisex nuance it may have had at first and which I certainly never recognised clearly. It’s an exquisite, classy perfume. It makes you feel good, confident, clean and dynamic. With reasonable projection and longevity it is excellent for the office in not excessively hot temperatures. I see it more for formal settings, although on spring and autumn nights it is ideal for evenings out with friends or family. I don’t know if it’s still in production, later I’ll check the batch on the bottle and post it for you. It can still be found online and at a very interesting price of about £20. I recommend its use from age 30; not because it feels old-fashioned on young people, but because there are better fragrances for these age ranges and I don’t think it suits current trends. It will always be in my collection, that’s for sure. For me it’s a hidden gem of perfumery. Greetings fellow fragrance lovers!!! NOTE: I checked on checkfresh and the manufacturing date is May 2018. 1 year before the purchase date.

    Reply
  22. Exquisite sophisticated scent, it reminded me for a moment of Pierre Cardin the one in the green box note (it doesn’t appear in the database here) a combination of woods and citrus that wraps you and leaves a charming pleasant balanced trail its wear on my skin is about 6 hours not bad I give it 9/10 I fell in love with this fragrance.

    Reply
  23. Oscar.mimosa

    At the start, lime stands out with a touch of mandarin. It then evolves centred around the spices, above all cardamom and pepper, with a hint of coriander. It has too classic a dry-down and nowadays very generic in masculine perfumes of this type. I find this perfume has nothing oriental about it as I don’t really notice the sandalwood and even less the ebony wood. For me its true classification is Woody Spicy. It doesn’t have great sillage and its longevity is moderate. And I cannot understand why on English Fragrantica so many people found it similar to Chanel’s Egoiste, which I also own. In my judgement they bear no resemblance at all. The strength and expressiveness of Chanel’s sandalwood is enough to tell it apart from this CK.

    Reply
  24. MarenLavande

    It’s a fragrance that can’t be missing from my collection, with an uncommon aroma. It goes through a variety of changes as the hours pass, it feels very fresh and spicy in the opening, then woody notes. But in extreme heat, the Mandarin stands out (spectacular). Although it hasn’t received many reviews. I’ll buy it over and over again. Excellent

    Reply
  25. Contradiction by Calvin Klein. A fragrance that passed without glory through my collection. It was a very metallic citrus fragrance that never quite pleased me. It belonged to the breed of perfumes where I sprayed a lot to finish it quickly. It had a bitter grapefruit touch in the opening and then gave way to the middle notes where pepper and cinnamon appeared as predominant. Calvin Klein has been one of those houses born to break everything but then ended up releasing an extravagant amount of very low quality fragrances, almost like supermarket perfumes. How far behind are the Eternity and the Escapes! Decent, nothing more. I wouldn’t buy it again. Rating: 4/10

    Reply
  26. It’s an infamous fragrance, after logically buying it blind, if you try it you run away, I’ve used it as a bathroom air freshener.

    Reply
  27. Not bad at all, it’s an old fragrance. It projects little and has a weak trail, though the price is reasonable. I would hardly buy it again.

    Reply
  28. marcosluparia

    Contradiction by Calvin Klein. A fragrance that passed through my collection without much fuss or glory. It was a very metallic citrus that never quite won me over. It belonged to that breed of perfumes where you had to spray a lot to finish it quickly. It had a bitter grapefruit opening to then give way to the middle notes where pepper and cinnamon appeared as predominant. Calvin Klein has been one of those houses born to break everything but then ended up releasing an odd amount of very low-quality fragrances, almost like supermarket perfumes. How far they have come from the Eternity and the Escapes. Correct, nothing more. I wouldn’t buy it again. Rating: 4/10.

    Reply
  29. marcosluparia

    A contradiction from Calvin Klein. It passed without glory in my collection. It was citrusy and metallic, never quite to my taste. I had to spray a lot to finish it quickly. It opened with a bitter grapefruit note, then pepper and cinnamon took over. CK was born to break everything, but later released a host of low-quality scents, almost supermarket standard. How far Eternity and Escapes have come. Correct, nothing more. I would not buy it again. 4/10

    Reply