Men
Milk
Acordes principales
Descripción
Milk by Commodity is an oriental woody fragrance for men and women. Launched in 2021, this composition features marshmallow (candy) and milk in the top notes; musk and white cedar extract in the heart; and woody notes and amber in the base.
Resumen rápido
Cuándo llevarla (votos)
Notas clave
Comunidad
932 votos
- Positivo 72%
- Neutral 16%
- Negativo 12%
Pirámide olfativa
Estructura completa de la fragancia: de la salida al fondo.
Comunidad
Qué dicen los usuarios sobre propiedad, preferencia y mejor momento de uso.
Propiedad
¿La tienen, la tuvieron o la quieren?
Preferencia
Cómo valora la comunidad esta fragancia.
Uso recomendado
Estación y momento del día con más votos.
Dónde comprar
Compara tiendas verificadas para Milk y elige según envío, precio o disponibilidad.
Amazon
Envío rápidoEntrega rápida y política de devoluciones conocida.
Ideal si priorizas velocidad y disponibilidad.
Ver en AmazoneBay
Más opcionesMás opciones de precio, formatos y vendedores.
Útil para comparar alternativas antes de decidir.
Ver en eBayCaracterísticas
Resumen de votos sobre longevidad, estela, género y percepción de precio.
Longevidad
Escasa
Débil
Moderada
Duradera
Muy duradera
Estela
Suave
Moderada
Pesada
Enorme
Género
Femenino
Unisex femenino
Unisex
Unisex masculino
Masculino
Precio
Extremadamente costoso
Ligeramente costoso
Precio moderado
Buen precio
Excelente precio
Reseñas
Experiencias reales de la comunidad sobre uso diario, rendimiento y estela.
Para dejar una reseña necesitas iniciar sesión.
2 reseñas
Mostrando las más recientes primero.
Category:
Men
Milk +
Acordes principales
Descripción
Milk + by Commodity is an oriental woody fragrance for men and women. Launched in 2021, this composition features top notes of marshmallow (candy) and milk; a heart of white cedar extract and musk; and a base of woody notes and amber.
Resumen rápido
Cuándo llevarla (votos)
Notas clave
Comunidad
1,833 votos
- Positivo 74%
- Negativo 13%
- Neutral 13%
Pirámide olfativa
Estructura completa de la fragancia: de la salida al fondo.
Comunidad
Qué dicen los usuarios sobre propiedad, preferencia y mejor momento de uso.
Propiedad
¿La tienen, la tuvieron o la quieren?
Preferencia
Cómo valora la comunidad esta fragancia.
Uso recomendado
Estación y momento del día con más votos.
Dónde comprar
Compara tiendas verificadas para Milk + y elige según envío, precio o disponibilidad.
Amazon
Envío rápidoEntrega rápida y política de devoluciones conocida.
Ideal si priorizas velocidad y disponibilidad.
Ver en AmazoneBay
Más opcionesMás opciones de precio, formatos y vendedores.
Útil para comparar alternativas antes de decidir.
Ver en eBayCaracterísticas
Resumen de votos sobre longevidad, estela, género y percepción de precio.
Longevidad
Escasa
Débil
Moderada
Duradera
Muy duradera
Estela
Suave
Moderada
Pesada
Enorme
Género
Femenino
Unisex femenino
Unisex
Unisex masculino
Masculino
Precio
Extremadamente costoso
Ligeramente costoso
Precio moderado
Buen precio
Excelente precio
Reseñas
Experiencias reales de la comunidad sobre uso diario, rendimiento y estela.
Para dejar una reseña necesitas iniciar sesión.
7 reseñas
Mostrando las más recientes primero.
-
scentedjimenq
I wasn’t expecting this from the name. I was looking for something milky and creamy, but on my skin it’s 98% strong, astringent, and dry wood, with only 2% sweetness. It gave me a headache quickly. It has three phases: 1. The first 2-3 minutes feature a subtle milky scent that instantly turns into realistic marshmallow. 2. Soon after, a dark, dry, powdery wood (tonka bean) kicks in; it’s very intense and strong, lasts 3-4 hours, and made
-
scentedjimenq
I wasn’t expecting this from the name. I was looking for something milky and creamy, but on my skin it’s 98% strong, astringent, and dry wood, with only 2% sweetness. It gave me a headache quickly. It has three phases: 1. The first 2-3 minutes feature a subtle milky scent that instantly turns into realistic marshmallow. 2. Soon after, a dark, dry, powdery wood (tonka bean) kicks in; it’s very intense and strong, lasts 3-4 hours, and made me dizzy. 3. Finally, there’s barely a trace of sweet baby milk left. It’s unisex, but leans masculine.
-
Doménica
I put on Milk Commodity Bold + again and it was like reconnecting with something I already know I love. What a delight. I like it much more than Bianco Latte, which never fully won me over (in fact, my husband uses it more 😅).
-
Taurien
Although I expected something very milky, this perfume moves more into woody territory. It is warm, creamy, and cosy, but it doesn’t smell like realistic milk; the milky aspect is only noticeable at the start and never stands out on me. The woods do stand out, especially the sandalwood, with an amber base and a musky touch that gives it body. I’ve liked it quite a bit and I think it’s ideal for winter. It has echoes of This Is Her due to the sandalwood, but it is less sweet and dense. It doesn’t smell like By The Fireplace or Ameer Al Oud Intense because it lacks smoky or saffron notes. Sillage is moderate-to-intimate, lasts over 10 hours (only the first hour close to the skin). Scent 6.5/10, Longevity 10/10, Sillage 6.5/10, Value for money 4.5/10, Versatility 6/10, Packaging 8/10. Would I buy again? No.
-
csaavfer
If Milk Expressive was for me the ultimate expression of a milky perfume, this Milk+ Bold is very similar but clearly less milky. Instead of that pure evaporated milk aroma, I perceive much more wood with a very noticeable sweet smoky touch, which evokes a cloud of marshmallows toasting over a slow fire. A super warm and cosy scent. For me, it’s 100% autumn/winter and for evening/night; I can’t see myself wearing it to work. It is more unisex than Expressive, but I think it will generally appeal more to women. The performance is more opulent but not beast mode, with similar longevity. I am a huge fan of this line; it seems unique and I love it. However, I feel it is redundant to have all three in my collection. I have the 100ml bottle of Expressive and 10ml of this, which I think is enough.
-
Amethyste
This fragrance is a cosy hug for cold days; you feel like you’re by a fire roasting marshmallows. Nothing like This Is Her by Z&V, watch out for buying blindly even though both are milky and woody. It is quite woody; don’t expect an ultra-gourmand aroma from the marshmallows because it isn’t one; it’s warm milk wrapped in cedar wood. It is perfectly unisex; at first I felt it was very masculine but I adapted because I had never smelled anything like it before. Milk+ is different from everything I’ve tried and that attracts me. It lasts approx 6-8 hours, with moderate sillage that drops to skin-level at the end, but you still feel wrapped up.
-
anndrea12
In my opinion, this milk version is the sweetest: a woody, smoky, and very sweet marshmallow, slightly milky. It is the sweetest of all. If you like sweet, woody, and slightly milky fragrances, you will love it. It is very sexy, cosy, and different.
Category:
Men
Milk
Acordes principales
Descripción
Milk by Commodity is an oriental woody fragrance for men and women. Launched in 2021, the nose behind this composition is Christelle Laprade. The top note is milk; the heart notes are marshmallow (candy) and natural musk; the base notes are cedar and tonka bean.
Resumen rápido
Cuándo llevarla (votos)
Notas clave
Comunidad
3,871 votos
- Positivo 70%
- Neutral 15%
- Negativo 15%
Pirámide olfativa
Estructura completa de la fragancia: de la salida al fondo.
Comunidad
Qué dicen los usuarios sobre propiedad, preferencia y mejor momento de uso.
Propiedad
¿La tienen, la tuvieron o la quieren?
Preferencia
Cómo valora la comunidad esta fragancia.
Uso recomendado
Estación y momento del día con más votos.
Dónde comprar
Compara tiendas verificadas para Milk y elige según envío, precio o disponibilidad.
Amazon
Envío rápidoEntrega rápida y política de devoluciones conocida.
Ideal si priorizas velocidad y disponibilidad.
Ver en AmazoneBay
Más opcionesMás opciones de precio, formatos y vendedores.
Útil para comparar alternativas antes de decidir.
Ver en eBayCaracterísticas
Resumen de votos sobre longevidad, estela, género y percepción de precio.
Longevidad
Escasa
Débil
Moderada
Duradera
Muy duradera
Estela
Suave
Moderada
Pesada
Enorme
Género
Femenino
Unisex femenino
Unisex
Unisex masculino
Masculino
Precio
Extremadamente costoso
Ligeramente costoso
Precio moderado
Buen precio
Excelente precio
Reseñas
Experiencias reales de la comunidad sobre uso diario, rendimiento y estela.
Para dejar una reseña necesitas iniciar sesión.
16 reseñas
Mostrando las más recientes primero.
-
Mireiaps
Oud bathed in milk.
-
Ysera
First trying it from the discovery kit gave me a shock: everyone said it smelled of creamy marshmallows, but to me it just sounded like smoky wood. I kept sniffing the sample until I realised I was falling in love. I’ve even sniffed the empty bottle until I finally bought it. It’s addictive. If you press your nose to the skin, it smells of smoky wood. But as a whole, yes, it does smell of marshmallows with milk, toasted. It’s a very different perfume, even abstract. In my opinion, it’s totally autumnal and winter, it doesn’t work in summer. It’s a very enjoyable scent, sweet and warm.
-
Lonit
Much less lactonic than one might expect from a perfume with that name and those notes. It may have a distant air of milk, but I’d say this is gourmand wood. I like it for being at home in winter; it feels comforting.
-
Pablova
It was a blind buy; I bought it because I heard it was very pretty and smelled different. To be honest, I’m not a fan of lactonic notes, but this perfume is the exception. I like that it’s sweet and soft but with woody undertones that balance this sweetness so it’s not cloying. It reminds me of a scene from Ponyo, when children drink milk warmed with honey and cinnamon; if I imagine how that drink smells, this perfume comes to mind. It’s a scent I recommend for day and night, cold or fresh days, but for very hot days it’s better to skip it as it can feel heavy and cloying.
-
Pablova
It was a blind purchase because it said it smelled different and looked pretty. To be honest, I’m not a fan of milky scents, but this is the exception. I like that it’s sweet and soft, with a woody base that balances the sweetness so it doesn’t become cloying. It reminds me of the Ponyo movie, when the children drink milk warmed with honey and cinnamon; I imagine smelling that drink and this fragrance comes to mind. I recommend it for day and night, in cold or crisp days, but avoid it in intense heat as it may feel heavy.
-
Aurorakmz
With this perfume I went through three phases: 1. When I was reading reviews without having smelled it, imagining what it would be like. 2. When my friend gifted it to me and I was expecting a different scent. 3. When I tried it on skin and fell completely in love. Conclusion: I had an idea in my head that turned out to be different but better than I expected. The opening smells very much of milk, but when it settles on skin, it becomes a sweet but woody scent, like a marshmallow burnt over the fire. It’s not as lactonic as I expected, but it has a creamy touch that reminds me of the foam on hot milk. On my skin it’s quite sweet, but with that touch of cedar that woody-ifies the aroma. I’ve loved it and think it suits me very well. It doesn’t have much trail or longevity, but it’s addictive and I love smelling myself when I wear it.
-
Probadoaprobado
Sweet fragrance, lactonic and more woody than it initially appears. At first, the lactonic component is much more noticeable, reminiscent of condensed milk or clouds; however, as it dries down, the cedar wood notes come to the fore, making it less gourmand and darker than at first. It gives me a cosy feeling in winter due to the musk, but I don’t see it in other times of the year as it can feel heavy. You can tell the quality of its ingredients, and on me it has a longevity of about six hours with low projection. It doesn’t resemble Zara’s Red Temptation & Vanille. If you want to see the comparison with the Zara perfume, you can find it on my Instagram, TikTok and YouTube @probadoaparobado.
-
lorzastyle
Too much musk for me.
-
Probadoaprobado
A sweet, milky, and more woody fragrance than it appears. At first, the milky notes dominate, reminding one of condensed milk or clouds, but as it dries down, the cedar woods emerge, making it less gourmand and darker. It gives me a cosy winter feeling due to the musk, but I don’t see it for other seasons as it can feel heavy. The quality of the ingredients is noticeable; on me, it lasts about six hours with low projection. It doesn’t resemble Zara’s Red Temptation & Vanille. If you want to see the comparison, follow me on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube @probadoaparobado.
-
Kuperku
I love it. It smells super lactonic and sweet, dense, and has a spectacular longevity. I could still smell it strongly at 5-6 hours, and my partner confirmed they could smell it on me. Then I went to bed, but this morning I still have a small touch of Milk. I also have the Milk Bold, for which I sprayed a couple of pulses to add some punch. I love both; perhaps the second is slightly smokier, but very similar.
-
Paola.PT
Finally I found how to describe this fragrance: it smells of baby vomit. But of mother’s milk vomit, sweet and slightly acidic. It sounds disgusting but I struggle to think anyone would dislike the smell of a baby drinking milk. I LOVE IT.
-
Mamgoiam
It’s a good perfume; it lasted quite a while and it’s a very original scent, but on my skin I detect too much burnt wood. I like the sweet and creamy marshmallow point, and the wood suits it, but I’d like it to be less smoky (though I admit it would be less original). It seems as if you’ve come from the village and have been sitting too long in front of the fireplace. Edit to say my flatmate asked me if something was burning, as it smells of smoke, so I confirm it wasn’t my imagination.
-
JohnAcosta25
I tried it as a sample and at first it smells of condensed milk, yet without being cloying. How can it be a daily wear? The secret lies in the dry-down: it becomes sweet, woody, with a powdery-attar touch. Imagine opening a bag of chocolates and placing them over a flame without smoke; that’s the scent. To me, it’s entirely feminine and winter-appropriate, ideal for staying at home or intimate gatherings. It would suit a grandmother or someone delicate who bakes cookies in the dead of winter perfectly.
-
anndrea12
If you’re looking to buy it for the marshmallow note, beware: it’s not a common sweet marshmallow, it’s different! I’d rate it as warm, sweet, milky, smoky, and creamy. You can taste the toasted marshmallow and a very warm spiced wood base. It’s unisex with a feminine leaning, but packed with sexy personality. If you enjoy sweet and woody scents, you’ll adore this.
-
csaavfer
Although it may seem obvious, if you love milky notes, this is your perfume. It opens with pure, creamy, sweet milk, an absolute and hyper-realistic protagonist. It was a total surprise; I’d never smelled anything like it, yet it doesn’t come across as jarring; it wears well even though it smells like a glass of hot milk. After a few minutes, the milk blends with a woody and slightly smoky base, transforming into a cloud of slowly toasting marshmallows. That part is my favourite: exquisite, cosy, and comforting. It’s not for drawing attention nor necessarily sexy, but an intimate, mysterious, and captivating scent, like an enhanced second skin. It has earned compliments from both men and women. In my opinion, it’s 100% unisex. Projection is moderate for the first two hours, then an intimate trail with notable longevity of about six hours. I know it could be better, but it’s not bad. In short: I love it and I’m getting a bottle.
-
DonRober
The opening is unique: it smells of evaporated milk in a tin (like Carnation) for about seven minutes. Afterwards, it reveals a sweet candy with a light sweetness meeting the aroma of a campfire and smoky tones, staying close to the skin on the dry-down. I find it fully feminine, a fragrance with a homely air.
Category:




In this milk version, I notice more marshmallow and milk, but it’s not an overpowering sweetness; it’s a musky, airy, woody marshmallow with a very subtle sweetness as it dries down. Gourmand, musky, and woody lovers will adore it. Like the rest of the range, it’s incredibly sexy and cosy.
I tried it from the Discovery Kit and it caught me off guard: it smells like freshly washed skin and pure sweetness, like marshmallow with a dusting of powder, milky notes and lots of musk. Milk Expressive adds a touch of smoky wood, but they’re very similar. It’s perfect when you want to feel clean without the fuss—a truly special fragrance.